Tag Archives: Kansas City

Upstarts: MP3

Tunes on the Web A Little Net Music The way we listen to music is about to change. Again. But as usual, where there’s change, there’s start-up opportunity. Before 1997, MP3 was a little-known technology that computer geeks used to download compressed music files free off the Internet. But Internet time moves fast — so fast that by 1998 large pockets of the general public and the mainstream media were talking about MP3, not to mention taking advantage of it. At first the music moguls were afraid of MP3. Protecting copyrights was hard enough without easily accessible Web files enabling any old joes to access — and copy — their favorite music. But when the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) started filing lawsuits against the Web sites and technology companies responsible for providing that capability, it was clear the industry had started to take MP3 seriously. Music on the Web was going to be big. Today on the Internet, only the word sex generates more searches than the term MP3 does. Musically inclined Web surfers can purchase their favorite CDs and listen to the radio online, download their favorite songs, and even custom design CDs. And wouldn’t you know it, start-ups have begun springing up in a variety of niches to capitalize on the digital-music revolution. Hey, kids — what’s that song? During that rare block of commercial- and chat-free music on your favorite radio station, you hear that song. You know, that song, the one you hum all day during work. The one you just have to own. If only the DJ would stop the music long enough to tell you the name of that song. But alas, the music continues without interruption, and you’re left with a void in your CD library, and the record company with a void in its sales. That happened to Robert Goldman just often enough for him to identify a gap in the retail music market. Goldman, who has a degree in psychology, studied impulse buying — specifically, what drives consumers to purchase CDs. His findings suggest that the radio generates 95% of the impulse for buying music. “You listen to the radio, and if you like what you hear, you’re going to buy it,” Goldman says. That is, of course, if you know what you’re listening to. And that’s where GetMedia Inc., Goldman’s start-up, based in San Jose, Calif., comes in. Noting the emergence of Internet music sites and the popularity of E-commerce, Goldman saw the Web as the perfect environment to track radio-station play lists in. In 1997 he gathered a development team to create technology that would help radio listeners follow what their favorite stations were playing in real time. Further, he embedded a commerce option in it so listeners could purchase music directly from their trusted radio stations, bringing the point of purchase directly to the point of impulse. GetMedia launched its Web service in May 1999 and went live on a handful of stations, including Mix 93.3, the CBS/Infinity Broadcasting station in Kansas City, Mo., which started using the service in November. Now when Mix 93.3 FM broadcasts, say, “Learn to Fly,” a popular single from the band Foo Fighters, listeners can tune their Internet browsers to www.Mix93.com, click on the “Now Playing” link, and find a list of recently played songs, with their album titles and the time Mix 93.3 played them. Play lists also feature “info” icons next to each listing, where, for instance, Foo Fighters fans can get in-depth information about the band’s latest album, There Is Nothing Left to Lose. Site visitors can even sample songs from the CD. Of course, the real key to this application is the “Buy” icon. After just a few clicks and a credit-card number, GetMedia will ship There Is Nothing Left to Lose to a Mix 93.3 listener, and the station will pick up some extra cash. “This lets the radio station make money on music they already play for free,” Goldman says. GetMedia takes a percentage of each sale — a revenue model similar to that of major credit-card companies. And unlike online music retailers, GetMedia taps into established radio-station audiences and doesn’t need to spend millions on driving traffic to its own site. So far, 35 radio stations throughout the country have gone live with the service. Some 2,200 stations are on GetMedia’s waiting list, but Goldman doesn’t have the resources to set them up as fast as he’d like. Last September, GetMedia got some help to the tune of $10 million in venture capital from IDG Ventures, Menlo Ventures, and the Rosewood Stone Group. Goldman plans to use that cash to beef up his 60-person staff and outfit those stations awaiting the service. Record label goes digital There’s a part of the music industry that thrives on rock-and-roll renegades that lead the way to sweeping change. The current indie darling of the Internet music scene is Al Teller, who a few years ago was anything but independent. Since receiving two engineering degrees from Columbia and an M.B.A. from Harvard, Teller has had a 30-year career that includes stints as the head of MCA Music Entertainment Group and president of CBS Records. In February 1999, Teller took the plunge with his own capital and launched Atomic Pop, a fusion of music, radio, video games, and television that all comes together at www.atomicpop.com in what looks to be a model for the record label of the future. Teller’s label offers artists a better deal than they can get from the major record labels. Artists can use the site for promotion and distribution, and to supplement traditional retail channels with online sales. “The basic deal is a 50-50 split of the profits,” Teller says. “Majors’ star royalty is roughly 20% of retail price. Per unit, with us, artists can make twice what they’re making at the major labels.” By cutting the multilayered fat of giant marketing and promotions divisions, the 30-employee Atomic Pop hopes it can enjoy heftier margins than the majors do. This new way of doing business was music to the ears of rap giants Public Enemy, the first group that signed with Atomic Pop. Last May, Atomic Pop promoted Public Enemy’s new album, There’s a Poison Goin’ On, and sold it on the site for $10 before it was available in stores. Teller also sold digital downloads of the record for $8, a price that would be tough for majors and retailers to match. The real buzz for the album came with the prerelease single, which some 300,000 fans downloaded — free. Although Atomic Pop doesn’t have the marketing strength that major labels use to get new singles on the radio and on MTV, Teller notes that fans at his site have actively sought the song out instead of simply hearing it passively. “You have to proactively download a single,” he says. So far, There’s a Poison Goin’ On has sold about 90,000 copies — 10,000 of which were sold on the Internet. “And that ratio is going to change,” Teller promises. Still, those numbers represent about half the sales of Public Enemy’s previous albums. Teller blames the shortfall on a less extensive concert tour surrounding the new release. But he remains optimistic about future sales. Typically, he says, record sales fall off after promotional efforts cease. “We will continue to market and promote the record for months to come. The traditional labels will walk away from records after a short period of time.” For its first full year of business Atomic Pop saw revenues of about $2 million. The company has yet to turn a profit, but Teller anticipates one soon. By signing new groups such as the Gas Giants and creating a robust list of releases, Atomic Pop hopes to be aggressive in 2000. The company has also acquired the digital rights to 4AD — the British indie superlabel that boasts such 1980s punk stars as the Pixies and Bauhaus. Add that to its $10-million capital infusion from New Valley Corp. and a recent partnership with Microsoft, and Atomic Pop isn’t looking so indie anymore. The MP3 piracy police The RIAA is getting serious about piracy. It recently filed numerous lawsuits against music-related upstarts, claiming they’ve created a black market for illegal copies of digital music. But not everyone online is on the RIAA’s bad side. A handful of savvy start-ups have joined the antipiracy brigade by offering secure online distribution and easy-to-use licensing as a legal alternative to the MP3 free-for-all. Reciprocal Inc., headquartered in Buffalo, N.Y., operates on a simple principle: all music, whether it’s on CD, the Internet, or the Paleolithic eight-track tape, comes with an implicit license agreement. “You can’t legally make 1,000 CD copies and sell them on the street,” says Reciprocal senior vice-president Howard Singer. But online, it’s a different story. Music is far too easy to copy and distribute illegally, and sometimes consumers are entirely unaware of their own illegal activity. “You can buy a song from Emusic.com, put it on your computer, post it on a Web page, and send it to your friends,” says Singer. “There’s no technology in place to put any speed bumps in the way of doing that. And the major record labels don’t find that satisfactory.” Think of Reciprocal as a speed bump. It enables record labels to attach conditions to downloading and distributing protected intellectual property. Reciprocal handles the creation, storage, and issuing of licenses for digital property such as songs and research reports. Reciprocal then reports back to the content owners (record companies or publishing houses) on those transactions. The content owners in turn pay the recording artists any royalties due. Reciprocal started out as part of Softbank Corp., a Japanese holding company with interest in more than 120 Internet companies. It spun out in 1997 and has diversified its offerings to include services for the text- and software-publishing communities. But with the proliferation of digital music distribution, the market for such a service in music alone is huge. The concept has been a hit with the investment community. Last November, Reciprocal completed a $35-million round of mezzanine financing that included technology- and music-industry heavyweights like Hewlett-Packard, Xerox, and TVT Records. Microsoft had even made its own investment of $15 million in March 1999. Singer believes that although music currently represents the lion’s share of Reciprocal’s transaction-based revenues, its text-publishing division may ultimately become the company’s biggest moneymaker. And that’s just a simple matter of price point. Textbooks and research reports can cost buyers anywhere from $80 to $4,000. Even if consumers make a practice of downloading entire albums, Singer reminds us, “you’re still looking at a $10 to $15 item.” What the Heck Is MP3? Unless you’re a techie or a teen, you may not be familiar with MP3, the hot new method of music distribution. With MP3 the artist records his or her music in digital form and uploads the file for that music onto the Web. Consumers can then download files for their favorite tunes onto their computers and enjoy the music through their home sound systems. They can even store the files on special MP3 listening devices for their mobile listening pleasure. Q& A Music to Your Ears? To help sift through the hype surrounding MP3 technology and music on the Internet, Inc. enlisted Joanne Marino, CEO and editor-in-chief of Webnoize, a research company and news outlet based in Stoneham, Mass., that focuses on digital entertainment. Inc.: What are the basic challenges in the MP3 marketplace? Marino: The fundamental problem is that it’s hard to create a viable business in an environment where music is being given away for free. Young consumers are active shoppers and are easily swapping files. It makes it a tough environment to break into and actually make money. There are a lot of hot new music start-ups, and I don’t know if a lot of them will make it through the end of the year. Inc.: So who’s going to last? Marino: The businesses that are the most exciting in the long term are the ones that are able to build more meaningful relationships with the creators and consumers. They might offer higher royalties or increased market reach to the artist and maybe give consumers the ability to share music and information with other listeners. I’d be very wary of the so-called MP3 portals that are aggregating all these artists in one place but are not adding anything to the users’ experience. Inc.: Will we see a lot of acquisitions? Marino: A lot of these companies will have no choice but to sell. They don’t have viable business models. Right now, it’s a race. If you have the money and the means to make it through the full marathon, then you’ll do all right. A lot of these companies don’t have any revenues coming in, and they’ll either get bought or go bankrupt. You can’t give everything away just to get people to pay attention to you. Inc.: Do you think we’ll be listening to CDs in 10 years? Marino: No. We’re going to be wearing our music like our clothing. Our experience is going to be mobile, it’s going to be personal, and it’s going to be intimate. But for us to get these kinds of services, we’re going to have to put up with a lot more marketing and advertising. That’s the catch-22. Please e-mail your comments to editors@inc.com.

Managing by the Web

An increasing number of Web sites promise to provide everything you need to run and grow your business. We asked real-world CEOs to try Type the phrase small business into Yahoo’s search engine and you’ll see there are 7,618 sites listed in 68 categories. Narrow your search down to entrepreneur and there are a mere 102 sites. The Web is bursting with brand-new destinations — we get an E-mail notice nearly every day about yet another one — purporting to solve all the problems and fill all the needs of small businesses. They offer expertise on management, finance, business planning, technology, and recruiting. They offer online tools for creating business plans, finding venture capital, and scoping out the competition. And they provide chat rooms, where, they claim, you can engage in hearty discourse with like-minded CEOs. Naturally, they also sell every kind of office product you may ever need. In short, these sites bill themselves as one-stop shopping for busy CEOs coping with the day-to-day challenges of running a growing business. And you can do it all from the cozy comfort of your desk. It sounded great to us. Wouldn’t it be nice if you actually could manage your business entirely by the Web? So we sorted through hundreds and hundreds of sites and culled the 10 best of the general-interest small-business offerings. (In the interest of full disclosure: Inc. has its own Web site — inc.com, which is a sister company to the one that publishes this magazine. To avoid any potential for conflict of interest, we are leaving our site off the list.) Then we asked a panel of 34 CEOs and entrepreneurs to put the promises made by the sites to the test. We had them evaluate the wide array of online offerings and let us know which ones were worth checking out — and which were a complete waste of time. Boy, did they ever. Our CEOs told us in no uncertain terms that most of the sites weren’t up to snuff for business builders who live in the real world. We’d picked experienced CEOs and company leaders who described their Internet savvy as “good.” And we asked them to rate each site based on 40 criteria, including sophistication of content, quality of experts, and usefulness of online tools. Most important, we asked them if they would ever go back to the site — and for what reason. So what passed the real CEO test? The answer was clear: not much. In general, the sites’ level of sophistication was far below what most heads of growing companies could really use. As one of them put it: “It’s like going to a sale. You go because you might find a deal, but generally you walk out of the store with things you don’t really need.” Still, our panel turned up worthwhile nuggets hidden here and there. One CEO, for example, raved about Onvia.com’s request for quote (RFQ) tool, saying it was “incredible — easy to use, comprehensive, and what a time-saver!” And even the harshest of our judges said they might go back to most of the sites for reference. Certainly, most of the sites offered worthwhile starting points for novice entrepreneurs looking for the basics. And after we had studied the sites for more than two months, one thing became clear to us: Web sites are changing and developing faster than you can imagine. What fails to meet CEO standards today may improve dramatically tomorrow. But there’s still a long way to go. As one disappointed CEO put it when asked if she’d go back to a particular site: “Never. Maybe for a zip code.” Read on for what our panel of CEOs had to say about the best of the offerings for small businesses on the Web. Additional reporting and site evaluations were provided by Inc. staffers Jill Hecht Maxwell, Anne Stuart, Christopher Caggiano, and Susan Greco. The Lowdown on the Sites We asked several senior Inc. staffers to give us their take on the 10 winning Web sites. (For reviews of sites run by nonprofits, see below.) Here’s what they had to say: AllBusiness.com All singin’, all dancin’, AllBusiness.com covers finance, human resources, sales and marketing, and office services, among other things. However, our CEO evaluators tell us that this Web powerhouse tries too much to be all things to all CEOs. Despite its easy-to-use design and good organization, it ends up being overwhelming in scope. Among its useful amenities: a “virtual file cabinet,” in which you can store documents or Web tools. There are also handy links to the site’s numerous partners and informal alliances: Lawyers.com (legal advice), Barnesandnoble.com (books), Onsale.com (auctions), AtYourOffice.com (office supplies), and so forth. DigitalWork.com This site offers small businesses help in doing such tasks as collecting bad debts, issuing press releases, listing a site on search engines, and posting jobs to recruiting sites. Don’t look here for free content or discussion groups. This is a down-to-business site with a handful of very specific functions. While some services, such as online travel booking, are available elsewhere, time-strapped novice CEOs may find DigitalWork.com’s one-stop convenience worth a visit. IdeaCafe.com Geared to new entrepreneurs, this site offers information, networking, and inspiration. It might be tempting to dismiss it as a neophyte-only destination, but Idea Cafe scores points for its disarming attitude and fresh point of view. Although many of our CEOs thought it might be good for beginners, they generally said they wouldn’t be going back. Its food motif (“chewy biz questions”) gets tiresome really fast. The sophistication level of the questions in the chat forums also could try the patience of any CEO, as could the chirpy responses from the “advisers” (read: consultants on a marketing mission) who seem to provide the lion’s share of the feedback. Office.com As one CEO put it, it’s hard to figure out exactly what Office.com is supposed to be until you’ve cruised the site awhile. But even navigating it isn’t easy. If you stick with it, what you’ll find is an array of online tools and software — some of them fun, most of them pretty basic. Maybe the best thing we can say about Office.com is that it provides a number of decent links to other sites as well as articles aimed mainly at beginners. Onvia.com You need a lawyer, some insurance, and a Web designer — and you need them yesterday. One place you can turn is Onvia.com, an ambitious online marketplace for small-business products and services. You may find some decent suppliers — or at least a good deal on PCs — from these folks. And one CEO raved about Onvia.com’s RFQ feature. At best, Onvia.com is a shopping mall for small businesses. Most of its attempts to offer broad content — such as the news-and-tools section — fall short. Don’t even waste your time there. SmartOnline.com Smart Online looks as if it offers a lot when you first get there. The site bills itself as having easy-to-use Web-hosted software to help people start, grow, and manage their businesses — but in reality, it’s damn hard to find your way around it. What we did figure out looked as if it would be interesting for beginners; it ranged from canned business letters to tools for creating financial statements. workz.com If you’re thinking of launching — or relaunching — your Web site without spending a lot of money, you may want to consider the resources of workz.com. For real beginners, the site delivers layer upon layer of how-to articles, checklists, and links. You’ll find everything a novice needs — from advice on how to build a Web site and maintain it to how to actually make money with it — discussed here in detail. Our CEOs didn’t have much time for workz.com, but we think it might not be bad for absolute beginners. Not for Profit Here’s the Inc. reviewers’ bottom line on the best of the Web sites that are not focused on making money from your business: edge.lowe.org Edge.lowe.org is the business library you wish you had down the street. Cleanly lit and well organized, it’s a good place to begin research on many start-up topics, from preparing a profit-and-loss statement to creating a marketing campaign. However, the fact that it’s run by a nonprofit shows. The content is all pretty basic and may frustrate more experienced entrepreneurs. EntreWorld.org The official Web site for the Kauffman Center for Entrepreneurial Leadership at the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation in Kansas City, Mo., is helpfully organized into three areas: “starting your business,” “growing your business,” and “supporting entrepreneurship.” While it does have some original content and some promising if ill-attended chat groups, Entreworld.org mostly just links you to other sites you might need. Some of the material is old, and it’s probably useful only for those just starting a business or wanting to be part of the entrepreneurship-education community. sba.gov Run by the Small Business Administration, this utilitarian site is the definitive source for small-business information from the government. Visitors can search a comprehensive online library about regulations, download loan forms and other documents, and take “workshops” in tasks such as preparing a business plan. The material is at the beginner level and often needs updating. (Y2K information was still on the site in February.) But the site is well set up and a snap to search. The Savvy CEO’s Guide to the Small-Business Web What CEOs say about the best of the Web offerings for small business Would our CEOs go back? What is the site good for? CEOs’ quick take AllBusiness.com “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Reference “This site relates to small businesses and start-ups with little previous experience. Not the sort of site I look to for advice.” DigitalWork.com “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Applications, one- stop shopping, purchasing “Applications seem useful, especially to newcomers. But those applications are limited to 11 functions.” IdeaCafe.com “Never.” Training for novices “What’s the mission? Business or humor?” Office.com “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Training, reference, purchasing “I didn’t have a clue as to what the site is about. If I wasn’t critiquing this site, I probably would have surfed right past it.” Onvia.com “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Purchasing “The RFQ tool was incredible. I needed a new printing company, and within minutes I had 15 responses.” SmartOnline.com “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Reference “Nothing on the site really captured my interest. Some relevance for those thinking about starting a business. Minimal relevance for me in helping run a business.” workz.com “Never.” Training for novices “The site is very general, designed for the very small company just getting into the Internet.” edge.lowe.org “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Training, reference “This site is good for ‘just in time’ learning on a variety of subjects all entrepreneurs will invariably deal with at various stages of growth.” EntreWorld.org “Occasionally, whenever I have a specific need.” Training, reference “Good links to other sites.” sba.gov “Never.” Training, reference “Good if it’s relevant to you — all SBA- and government-related.” Our Entrepreneur Judges Amilya Antonetti, president, Soapworks Jim Brock, partner, Amicus Chris Colbert, president, Holland Mark Edmund Ingalls John Coleman, president and cofounder, VIA Richard Colombik, president, International Tax Associates Eric Crown, CEO, Insight Enterprises Liz Elting, copresident, TransPerfect Translations Prashant H. Fadia, president and CEO, Abacus Software Group Maura FitzGerald, president and CEO, FitzGerald Communications Larry Gilbert, president, The Event Network Mark Gordon, CEO, Synergy Networks Ron Harris, president and CEO, Pervasive Software Charlie Horn, president and CEO, ScriptSave Karen Janson, CEO, 10 Minute Manicure Linda Kaplan, senior account executive, Identity Group Andrea Keating, president and CEO, Crews Control Linda Kellogg, founder and CEO, Start-Up Resources Deb Klein, founder, LMI Management Eric Kriss, president, Workmode.com Daryl Magana, founder, president, and CEO, Bidcom Marion McGovern, president, M Squared Debbi Milner, president and CEO, Jade Systems Glenn Neff, cofounder, Marketing Connections Brad Neuenhaus, president, TPC Steven Nickerson, chairman and CEO, Mucho.com Gerry Philpott, CEO and president, E-Poll.com Linda Pinson, owner, Out of Your Mind… and into the Marketplace Robert Posten, managing partner, Icon & Landis Eric Schechter, president, GAME: Great American Marketing & Events Randy Schilling, CEO and president, Solutech Eileen Shapiro, venture consultant, The Hillcrest Group Al Shariff, owner and president, GlobeTrends Marc Smith, CEO, NetStrategy Maura White, founder and CEO, GoBabies.com Crowded House Why are so many sites targeting you? With all the sites competing for the attention of companies like yours, small business has become one of the most hotly contested spaces on the Web. And why not? Small business is big business. There are some 15 million small companies in the United States today, according to the Small Business Administration. They employ more than half of the private-sector workforce. In 2000 they’ll spend $10 billion on personal computers alone, the Yankee Group estimates. And most important, small businesses are going online. No wonder Onvia.com, AllBusiness.com, Office.com, and the rest are lining up to give small-business owners advice, sell them office supplies, let them chat with other entrepreneurs, and even — in the case of Idea Cafe — tutor them in the gentle art of paper-airplane folding. (See the site for an, er, explanation. Yes, it claims it helps you understand leadership.) And the Web-service boom also explains why, for instance, NBC Internet Inc. agreed to pay $225 million to buy AllBusiness.com, on February 1, which was the same day that DigitalWork.com filed for an initial public offering. “Internet penetration into small businesses is higher than ever. At the end of the year it will be close to 80%,” says Internet analyst Kneko Burney of Cahners In-Stat Group. “It’s a huge opportunity.” Overall, Burney says, more than 30 companies that provide small-business destination sites have plunged into the fray, 19 of them in a serious way. Although the revenue models vary, most of the companies aim to sell business-related services, content, or products, sometimes through partnerships with other E-vendors. “The Web really allows the creation or potential creation of a channel to what has historically been a very fragmented market — and very difficult to reach,” says Teymour Boutros-Ghali, CEO of AllBusiness.com (and, yes, the nephew of that Boutros-Ghali). Founded by an accountant, a lawyer, and a serial entrepreneur, and armed with $20 million in venture-capital backing, AllBusiness.com offers entrepreneurs help with legal matters and human resources over the Internet — “all the things that small businesses hate to do,” says Boutros-Ghali. In classic Web fashion AllBusiness.com is gunning for market share over profits and doesn’t plan to break into the black until 2002. E-commerce marketplace Onvia.com, launched in 1997, has attracted some impressive bets, too, including $71 million in financing from Internet Capital Group and other investors. With total revenues since its founding of $28 million and net losses of $44 million, Onvia.com was heading for an IPO at press time. By comparison, the cozy, playful Idea Cafe, a bootstrapped operation with revenues of less than $1 million, seems more like a labor of love. But, says founder Francie Ward, who runs the site with five part-time employees, it does make a profit, with revenues primarily from banner advertising. Back in the 1980s, when she was publishing small-business manuals, Ward figured that what entrepreneurs really wanted was to talk to other entrepreneurs, and her site offers that service. Workz.com founder David Johnson had a similar revelation. In the pre-Web world, he published newsletters for software users that boiled down a complex subject into simple, digestible tidbits. He started workz.com — which has $1 million in start-up funding — when he figured out that he could do the same thing over the Internet. On the other hand, not everyone sees the Web as a panacea. The Edward Lowe Foundation (named after the man who invented Kitty Litter) has had a Web site for small businesses since 1994. But last fall the foundation decided to supplement the site with a radically different channel for distributing information: an old-fashioned newsletter, printed on paper and sent out by snail mail. Says content-development manager Eric Vines, “A journal gains legitimacy if it has a print version.” –Emily Barker Please e-mail your comments to editors@inc.com.